• Home
  • General Information/FAQ
  • The Market Restaurant
  • Furniture & Home Goods
    • DUTCH CRAFT FURNISHINGS
    • STOLTZFUS VARIETY
  • DONUTS,BAKED GOODS,CANDY
    • AUNT MARTHA'S DONUTS
    • CORA'S COOKIES AND SUCH
    • THE CANDY CORNER
    • THE PRETZEL BAR
  • FRESH FOODS & PRODUCE
    • MARY'S SALADS
    • MILLER'S COUNTRY CORNER
    • SUNRISE DELIGHTS
    • YODER'S COUNTRY DELI
    • YODER'S FRUIT & PRODUCE
  • MEATS, POULTRY & SEAFOOD
    • HARLEY'S SMOKEHOUSE BBQ
    • KILLCREEK MEATS
  • Contact
  • More
    • Home
    • General Information/FAQ
    • The Market Restaurant
    • Furniture & Home Goods
      • DUTCH CRAFT FURNISHINGS
      • STOLTZFUS VARIETY
    • DONUTS,BAKED GOODS,CANDY
      • AUNT MARTHA'S DONUTS
      • CORA'S COOKIES AND SUCH
      • THE CANDY CORNER
      • THE PRETZEL BAR
    • FRESH FOODS & PRODUCE
      • MARY'S SALADS
      • MILLER'S COUNTRY CORNER
      • SUNRISE DELIGHTS
      • YODER'S COUNTRY DELI
      • YODER'S FRUIT & PRODUCE
    • MEATS, POULTRY & SEAFOOD
      • HARLEY'S SMOKEHOUSE BBQ
      • KILLCREEK MEATS
    • Contact
  • Home
  • General Information/FAQ
  • The Market Restaurant
  • Furniture & Home Goods
    • DUTCH CRAFT FURNISHINGS
    • STOLTZFUS VARIETY
  • DONUTS,BAKED GOODS,CANDY
    • AUNT MARTHA'S DONUTS
    • CORA'S COOKIES AND SUCH
    • THE CANDY CORNER
    • THE PRETZEL BAR
  • FRESH FOODS & PRODUCE
    • MARY'S SALADS
    • MILLER'S COUNTRY CORNER
    • SUNRISE DELIGHTS
    • YODER'S COUNTRY DELI
    • YODER'S FRUIT & PRODUCE
  • MEATS, POULTRY & SEAFOOD
    • HARLEY'S SMOKEHOUSE BBQ
    • KILLCREEK MEATS
  • Contact

Cora's Cookies & Such 330.406.8345

Made from Scratch Bakery

Looking for a delicious treat? We offer a wide variety of baked goods including cookies, cakes, cupcakes, cake rolls, cheesecakes, breads, buns, rolls, quick breads, gourmet breads, pies, cream pies, muffins, fruit streusel cakes, whoopie pies, and more!

HOMEMADE PIES, CREAM FILLED & FRUIT-FILLED

We make all of our pies fresh on-site at our Boardman location!

As you visit us to grab your preferred pie, you might witness our proficient bakers at work. Our process of crafting delectable pies commences with our exceptional pie crust dough, prepared to perfection. 

We only use top-notch ingredients, including in-season fruits for pie filling,  and other wholesome ingredients.



CREAM PIES

Cream Pies:

  • Banana
  • Chocolate
  • Coconut
  • Lemon Meringue*
  • Peanut Butter
  • Strawberry*


We usually have a few Cream Pies every week, but to guarantee that your favorite flavor is available, kindly drop by or call us to pre-order. 

We will ensure that your pie is ready for pick-up at your preferred time.



*This item is seasonal and can only be found during its respective season.

FEBRUARY CAKE OF THE MONTH - BLACK FOREST CAKE

FEBRUARY IS CHERRY MONTH! AVAILABLE THIS MONTH ONLY CHERRY CRUMB PIE

ON-SITE PIE BAKERY

Amish Bake Pies, Pie Bakery, Fresh Fruit Pies, Cream Pies, Ash Pies, Pie Bakery, Seasonal Pies
Pies, homemade pies, made from scratch pies, Amish baked pies Amish made pies, pie bakery,

Looking for a delicious treat? We offer a wide variety of baked goods including cookies, cakes, cupcakes, cake rolls, cheesecakes, breads, buns, rolls, quick breads, gourmet breads, pies, cream pies, muffins, fruit streusel cakes, whoopie pies, and more!

Coconut Cream Pie, Homemade Pie, Amish Made Pies, Pie Bakery, Fruit Pie, Peanut Butter Pie, Choc

COCONUT CREAM

Our Coconut Cream Pie is every bit as dreamy as it looks.

CORA'S COOKIES & SUCH

BREADS, ROLLS, BUNS, QUICK BREADS & SPECIALTY GOURMET BREADS

BREADS, ROLLS, BUNS, QUICK BREADS & SPECIALTY GOURMET BREADS

BREADS, ROLLS, BUNS, QUICK BREADS & SPECIALTY GOURMET BREADS

At Cora's, you'll find homemade breads in our bakery including White, Wheat, Whole Wheat, Oatmeal, Rye, Hot Pepper & many others. 

  • Dinner Rolls
  • Specialty Gourmet breads
  • Quick breads
  • Hot Dog & Hamburger Buns 
  • Bagels

Try one of our Specialty Gourmet Breads or add to your recipe, the Cinnamon Swirl takes French Toast to a new level of goodness!

COOKIES, BARS & MUFFINS

BREADS, ROLLS, BUNS, QUICK BREADS & SPECIALTY GOURMET BREADS

BREADS, ROLLS, BUNS, QUICK BREADS & SPECIALTY GOURMET BREADS

Weekly, you'll find an assortment of freshly baked muffins, cookies, bar cookies, loaves of bread, a variety of quick bread choices, plus seasonal favorites, cakes, cupcakes, pies and so much more. Everything is made from scratch, packaged, and ready for your enjoyment.

CAKES, CUPCAKES & CHEESECAKE

BREADS, ROLLS, BUNS, QUICK BREADS & SPECIALTY GOURMET BREADS

CAKES, CUPCAKES & CHEESECAKE

Coffee Cakes made fresh each week, right at our Boardman location! Try our traditional coffee cake or savor one of our fresh fruit topped coffee cakes (some are seasonal only).  

Increase the deliciousness with our homemade buttercream-filled coffee cake.

Cora's Cookies & Such

01/24

330.406.8345

BLUEBERRY CRUMB BARS

BLUEBERRY CRUMB BARS

BLUEBERRY CRUMB BARS

Bakery Fresh & filled with Fresh Blueberries (Seasonal)

COFFEE CAKES

BLUEBERRY CRUMB BARS

BLUEBERRY CRUMB BARS

Enjoy your favorite coffee cake made fresh from our bakery or take one along to share with friends or guests,  Perfect & delicious to take to a Get-Together.

GLUTEN-FREE

BLUEBERRY CRUMB BARS

GLUTEN-FREE

A Select variety of 

GLUTEN-FREE Bakery Items are available each week. Seasonal selection varies accordingly.

P: 330.406.8345

Butter Cream Filled Coffee Cake topped with our special glazing.

Cakes

     

  • Angel Food
  • Banana Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
  • Butter Pecan Cream Cake
  • Chocolate Cake with Fudge Icing
  • Chocolate Cake with White Icing
  • Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Icing
  • Cream Filled Coffee Cake
  • German Chocolate
  • Ho-Ho Cake
  • Yellow Cake with Coconut Icing
  • Yellow Cake with Fudge Icing


Sold Whole, Half or By the Slice.


Orders for Cakes & Custom Cakes Welcome! Call or visit us at The Amish Market located in Boardman, OH.

BLUEBERRY SWIRL CHEESECAKE, BLUEBERRY CHEESECAKE,

Cora's Cheesecakes


  • Blueberry
  • Caramel Apple*
  • Chocolate
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Creamy
  • Creamy with Fruit Topping
  • Lemon*
  • Mocha Swirl
  • Oreo
  • Peanut Butter
  • Peppermint*
  • Pumpkin*
  • Raspberry Swirl
  • Salted Caramel
  • S'Mores*
  • Turtle



Sold Whole, Half or By the Slice.


*Denotes Seasonal Item

Boston Cream Cake, Chocolate Icing, Custard cake,

Boston Cream Cake

Boston Cream Cake featuring Chocolate Icing and Custard that tastes just like the donut, but made from scratch cake.

Cinnamon Chocolate Chip Cake

Cinnamon Chocolate Chip Cake

A delicious Bundt cake filled with a Cinnamon Flavor Swirl and loaded with Chocolate Chips, topped off with our frosting & a few more chocolate chips.

Cheesecakes


Bakery Sampler (note, some items are seasonal only)

Homemade Ginger Bread Cookies, Gingerbread Man
Show More

Cora's Cookies & Such Menu

Cora's Cookies & Such Menu

NEW MENU IS COMING SOON! Prices subject to change without notice

Download Cora's Cookies & Such Menu PDF
  • Home
  • General Information/FAQ
  • Market Loyalty Program
  • The Market Restaurant
  • Contact

The Amish Market

6121 South Ave. Boardman, OH 44512

330.248.9933 General Market Phone

Copyright © 2025 The Amish Market - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

Cookie Policy

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you accept our use of cookies.

Accept & Close