6121 South Avenue, Youngstown, Ohio 44512



WALK-IN Shopping & Carry-out! We also have Curbside Pick-up

Amish Quality & Goodness in The Mahoning Valley

Indoor Amish Farmers Market

Open Year-Round & All Under One Roof!

In 2013 we opened our doors with one vision - to bring the Best of Amish Quality & Goodness to the Mahoning Valley & surrounding communities. We felt strongly that by limiting  our days of operation we could bring customers only the freshest in foods, baked goods, produce & dairy  weekly.

  • Originally established in 2013 as The Valley Marketplace, an indoor Amish Farmers Market filled with a variety of goods, vendors, furniture and furnishings.  In late 2017 the market fully became Amish Owned & Operated and the market renamed, The Amish Market.  
  • The market is comprised of just over 15 Amish vendors including quality Amish furniture & furnishings, home goods,  nature & outdoor decor,  the freshest in hot/cold foods, baked goods, meats, poultry, dairy, produce, and an on-site restaurant serving Home Cooked Amish Style Fare.    
  • OPEN THURSDAY - SATURDAY WEEKLY with the exception* of holy days or holidays  falling on these days. 
  • View our General Information Page or  current dates & other important market information.
  • You'll find us  in The Mathews Square Plaza on South Avenue (just North of Sam's Club) in Boardman, Ohio. 
  • The market is conveniently located just off I-680 and RT-224.

Around the Market

Around The Amish Farmers Market:

  • Experience a handmade Fry Pie loaded with the fruit & specialty fillings you love or grab incredibly yummy donuts from Aunt Martha's Donuts Donut & Coffee Shoppe and top it off with a hot coffee or choose a specialty coffee drink.
  • No time to cook? Bring home a delicious rack of barbeque ribs or rotisserie chicken from Harley's Smokehouse Barbeque. 
  • Several vendors offer various or select goods that are Gluten-Free, Organic, All-Natural or contain no additives, however this varies by product & vendor, please talk with the vendor.
  • Browse the beautiful Amish Furniture at Dutch Craft Furnishings. Bedroom, Dining, Entertainment, Office furniture & more!
  • Hungry? Dine-in at our on-site restaurant, The Market Restaurant serving up Amish Style Fare.
  • Then shop around the market and check out the incredible Amish foods & specialties for your grocery or entertaining needs.

                     We'll See You Around the Market! 

Subscribe to Our Weekly Exclusive Deals E-Mail

Subscribe here to receive our weekly E-mail of Exclusive Vendor Deals and Offers available at our Amish Farmers Market, ONLY subscribers receive these exclusive offers. Plus stay in the know about Seasonal Specialties, New Items, & Market Events.

Contact Us

The Amish Market

6121 South Ave. Boardman, OH 44512 US (Just North of Sams's Club)


The Amish Market Hours



Thursday & Friday: 9:00 am - 6:00 pm

Saturday: 8:00 am - 4:00 pm 

*Market Restaurant Hours:

Thursday & Friday: 8:00 AM - 5:15 PM

Saturday: 8:00 AM - 3:15 PM

*Market Restaurant Hours vary from Market Hours 

Want to send us a Message? 

We love to hear from our customers, send us a message by clicking the button below.  Please note, if you have a specific vendor or product question, to expedite the response please visit the vendor page in our website for further information and phone. 

Send Message